42nd Street Oyster Bar

Nestled in the heart of Raleigh, NC, 42nd Street Oyster Bar is a seafood restaurant and oyster bar that expertly blends classic Southern flavors with coastal charm. This vibrant spot at 508 W Jones St is a haven for seafood enthusiasts seeking fresh, flavorful dishes elevated by thoughtful preparation and quality ingredients.

The menu boasts a delightful array of offerings, beginning with their celebrated oysters—fresh, briny, and served with a touch of Southern elegance. Beyond the oysters, guests rave about the popcorn shrimp, generously portioned and tossed in a perfectly balanced Cajun seasoning that delivers a mild kick without overpowering the palate. For those craving something heartier, the crab and shrimp Alfredo is a standout, marrying creamy textures with the savory sweetness of fresh seafood.

Salads also deserve special mention, especially the Sesame Crusted Rare Ahi Tuna Salad, which pairs tender, seared tuna with crisp mixed greens and a zingy ginger dressing. Meanwhile, the Spinach Cocktail Shrimp Salad offers a refreshing blend of shrimp, cool cucumbers, and a lively, hot bacon dressing that's both comforting and invigorating.

Side dishes show meticulous care, from the fluffy baked sweet potato subtly kissed with butter and brown sugar to the housemade potato chips that provide a satisfying crunch. Collard greens and black-eyed peas, both enhanced with ham, offer a soulful nod to Southern roots, perfectly complementing the seafood-focused main courses.

As for the atmosphere, 42nd Street Oyster Bar embraces a dimly lit, cozy vibe that invites relaxed conversations and intimate dinners. Reviewers have noted the need for a little extra light when reading menus, but this low-key setting frames the dining experience as warm and unpretentious—a true neighborhood gem.

Customer experiences consistently highlight the attentive, friendly service that complements each meal. From complimentary hush puppies that welcome you to attentive waitstaff ready to guide menu choices, the staff's care amplifies the overall enjoyment. Slight quirks, like the occasionally chewier calamari or the smaller size of some oysters, are far outweighed by the depth of flavor and quality.

It’s no surprise then that many patrons choose 42nd Street Oyster Bar for special occasions—from birthdays to casual family celebrations—making it a cherished fixture in Raleigh’s culinary scene. The heartfelt fondness expressed by customers truly speaks to the genuine passion embedded in every dish and every interaction.

For those seeking authentic coastal dining paired with soulful Southern sides and a welcoming, intimate ambiance, 42nd Street Oyster Bar is a must-visit destination that leaves a lasting impression—one that seafood lovers and casual diners alike will treasure.

For reservations or takeout, call +1 919-831-2811 and prepare to savor the rich flavors and warm hospitality that define this Raleigh favorite.